Copyright in Munich: works, software, rights of use and infringements

Texts, images, graphics, logos, product designs, photographs, videos, software and databases are part of almost every product, website and advertisement. Copyright determines who may use them, who earns from them and what applies if they are copied without permission. We advise companies, creatives and developers on protecting their works, on structuring rights of use and in copyright infringement matters – on either side.

Alexander Ginzburg’s field of activity includes advice and representation in copyright matters.

What copyright protects

The German Copyright Act (UrhG) protects works of literature, science and art. Section 2(1) UrhG lists, by way of example, linguistic works such as writings, speeches and computer programs, musical works, works of pantomime and dance, works of fine art including architecture and applied art, photographic works, cinematographic works and illustrations of a scientific or technical nature such as drawings, plans, maps and tables.

A work is only protected if it is the author’s own intellectual creation (Section 2(2) UrhG): it must originate from a human being and make individual use of the available creative freedom. Purely routine, everyday or technically determined output is not sufficient. What is protected is the specific form, not the underlying idea, method or information: a concept, a business model or a style may be taken up by others, provided they do not copy the specific expression.

Designs, logos and applied art

Everyday objects, furniture, jewellery, packaging, graphics and logos can be protected as works of applied art. Since the Federal Court of Justice’s “Birthday Train” (Geburtstagszug) decision of 2013, they are not subject to stricter requirements than works of fine art. However, design features that are determined solely by technical considerations or by the intended use are disregarded; only what goes beyond that and is artistically designed is protected.

A logo can therefore be protected both by copyright and as a trade mark. Anyone who commissions a logo or a product design from an agency or a freelancer should expressly obtain the necessary rights of use – otherwise the designer may object to later uses, such as a trade mark application or an adaptation.

Software

Computer programs are protected as linguistic works; the special provisions of Sections 69a et seq. UrhG also apply to them. Protection covers all forms of expression of a program, in particular source code and object code, including preparatory design material. The only requirement is that the program is the author’s own intellectual creation; qualitative or aesthetic criteria play no role. Ideas and principles underlying any element of a computer program, including those underlying its interfaces, are not protected (Section 69a(2) UrhG).

The law allows a lawful user to perform certain acts without consent, such as making a back-up copy or, under narrow conditions, decompiling the program to achieve interoperability. Technical solutions implemented by software may, under certain circumstances, also be patentable (see Patents & utility models). With open-source software, the respective licence terms determine under which conditions the code may be used, modified and distributed; breaches of these terms can lead to the loss of the right to use it.

Databases

Databases can be protected in two ways. If the selection or arrangement of their contents is the author’s own intellectual creation, the database is a database work (Section 4(2) UrhG). Independently of this, the maker of a database obtains a right of its own if obtaining, verifying or presenting the contents required a substantial investment in qualitative or quantitative terms (Sections 87a et seq. UrhG). This database right protects the investment, not creativity, and in particular prohibits the extraction of substantial parts of the database. It expires 15 years after the database was published or made; substantial new investments can trigger a new term of protection.

Photographs

Photographs enjoy two levels of protection. If a photograph is individually designed, for example through the choice of subject, framing, light and perspective, it is a photographic work with full copyright protection. But simple photographs without any particular creativity – product shots, snapshots, pictures for an online shop – are also protected as photographs under a related right (Section 72 UrhG). This protection lasts 50 years from publication of the photograph or, if it has not been published, from its production.

Third-party photographs may therefore generally only be used with consent, even if they are freely available on the internet. Anyone who publishes photographs of people must also respect their right to their own image.

Creation, proof and term of protection

Unlike patents, trade marks and designs, a work protected by copyright does not need to be registered. Protection arises automatically when the work is created. In Germany there is no register showing authorship and the date of creation; both must be proven in a dispute. Drafts, version histories, source code repositories with timestamps, dated files and deposit with a notary or another trusted third party can make this proof easier.

Copyright expires 70 years after the death of the author (Section 64 UrhG); for joint authors, 70 years after the death of the last surviving author. The term runs until the end of the calendar year concerned. Related rights such as the right in simple photographs or the database right have shorter terms.

Moral rights

Copyright protects not only economic interests but also the author’s personal relationship with the work. This includes the right to decide on publication (Section 12 UrhG), the right to be recognised as the author, including the decision on whether and how the author is named (Section 13 UrhG), and the right to prohibit distortion or other impairment of the work that would jeopardise the author’s interests (Section 14 UrhG).

Under German law, copyright as such cannot be transferred, except by inheritance (Section 29 UrhG). Even a party that acquires comprehensive rights of use therefore does not become the author. Contracts can, however, govern whether and how the author is named and which adaptations are permitted.

Exploitation rights and rights of use

The author holds the exploitation rights, in particular the rights of reproduction, distribution and exhibition and the right of making the work available to the public, for example on the internet (Sections 15 et seq. UrhG). Others may only use the work in these ways if the author grants them a right of use or the law exceptionally permits the use.

Rights of use can be granted as non-exclusive or exclusive rights and can be limited in terms of territory, time or content (Section 31 UrhG). The purpose-of-transfer rule is decisive (Section 31(5) UrhG): if the types of use are not expressly specified individually, the other party will, in case of doubt, only acquire the rights needed for the purpose both parties had in mind when concluding the contract. A company that ordered a logo only for its website may therefore not simply use it on products or file it as a trade mark. Contracts should therefore expressly govern the types of use, territory, duration and the right to adapt and to sub-license or transfer.

The author is entitled to equitable remuneration (Section 32 UrhG) and, under certain conditions, to information on the extent of use of the work and the income generated. If the agreed remuneration is disproportionately low compared with the income later generated, the author can demand further participation.

Authors in employment and commissioned work

The author is always the person who created the work – even if they created it as an employee in the course of their duties. For employees, the general rules apply unless the content or nature of the employment relationship indicates otherwise (Section 43 UrhG). As a rule, the employer obtains the rights of use it needs for its business purposes; anything beyond that should be agreed in the contract.

A special rule applies to computer programs: if an employee creates a program in the performance of their duties or following the instructions of their employer, the employer alone is entitled to exercise all economic rights in the program, unless otherwise agreed (Section 69b UrhG).

These rules do not apply to freelancers, agencies and external developers. Without an express agreement, the client only obtains the rights required by the purpose of the contract. This often only becomes apparent when a company is sold, during an investor due diligence or in a dispute with the service provider. We review and draft the relevant contractual clauses (see Contracts).

Permitted uses: quotation, parody and pastiche

The law permits certain uses even without the author’s consent. Particularly important for companies is the right of quotation (Section 51 UrhG): a published work may be quoted if the quotation serves a particular purpose, such as engaging with the quoted work, and its extent is justified by that purpose. The source must be acknowledged. An image used merely to illustrate or decorate one’s own text is not a quotation.

Since 2021, the use of a work for the purposes of caricature, parody and pastiche has also been expressly permitted (Section 51a UrhG). How far this permission extends, particularly in the case of pastiche, has not yet been finally clarified by the courts. Other exceptions concern, for example, private copying, teaching and research, and incidental inclusion. Whether an exception applies depends heavily on the individual case; it should be checked before publication.

Artificial intelligence and copyright

Works within the meaning of copyright law require a human creation. Texts, images or code generated by an AI alone, without any decisive human creative contribution, are therefore not protected by copyright according to the prevailing view. The position may be different where a person uses AI as a tool and shapes the result through their own creative decisions. Where exactly the line lies has not yet been finally settled. Companies that exploit AI output commercially should therefore not simply assume that they acquire exclusive rights in it.

For the training of AI models, Section 44b UrhG permits text and data mining of lawfully accessible works. Rights holders can, however, reserve such use; for works accessible online, a reservation is only effective if it is made in machine-readable form. Conversely, AI output can reproduce third-party works or come so close to them that their use constitutes copyright infringement. Before AI output is published or marketed, it should therefore be checked whether it copies third-party works.

Protection abroad

Under the Berne Convention and other international treaties, works are protected in the contracting states without formalities, generally under the law of the country for which protection is claimed. Scope, term and exceptions may therefore differ from country to country. In some countries, such as the USA or China, voluntary registration can bring advantages in a dispute, in terms of evidence or of the claims that can be enforced. For cross-border infringements, for example through online shops, it should be examined where and under which law action can be taken most effectively.

Copyright infringement: claims and warning letters

Anyone who uses a work without permission can be required to cease and desist and to remove the infringement; if at fault, they are liable for damages (Section 97 UrhG). The rights holder can calculate damages as the actual loss, as the infringer’s profit or by way of a licence analogy, i.e. the amount reasonable parties would have agreed as remuneration for the use. In addition, there are claims to information, including against certain third parties such as service providers (Section 101 UrhG), and to destruction, recall and surrender of infringing copies (Section 98 UrhG). Claims generally become time-barred three years after the end of the year in which the rights holder became aware of the infringement.

Before court proceedings, the infringer should be sent a warning letter and given the opportunity to settle the dispute by a cease-and-desist declaration with a contractual penalty (Section 97a UrhG). The warning letter must contain certain information, such as a precise description of the infringement; an ineffective or unjustified warning letter can give rise to counterclaims. Against private individuals, the recoverable costs of a warning letter are capped under certain conditions. In urgent cases, a prohibition can be obtained by way of a preliminary injunction.

We represent rights holders in enforcing their rights. Companies that have received a warning letter are advised on whether the claims asserted exist, whether the sender actually holds the rights, whether an exception applies and how a cease-and-desist declaration can be limited where appropriate. A pre-drafted cease-and-desist declaration should not be signed without review, as it often goes further than the infringement.

Platforms and online services

Special rules apply to platforms on which users upload content. Under the German Copyright Service Providers Act, large online content-sharing services are in principle themselves responsible for the uploaded content and must make efforts to obtain licences or, under certain conditions, block the availability of notified works. Rights holders can report infringements through the platforms’ notification procedures. Anyone who finds their own content wrongly blocked can also complain. For a company’s own websites and online shops, every embedded image, text and video should be used on the basis of a demonstrable right of use.

Relationship with designs, trade marks and unfair competition law

Copyright, design rights, trade mark rights and protection against imitation under unfair competition law can coexist and complement each other. Copyright arises without registration and lasts a long time, but requires a level of creativity that has to be demonstrated in a dispute. A registered design protects the appearance of a product from registration for up to 25 years, regardless of any artistic merit (see Designs). A trade mark protects a sign as an indication of origin and can be renewed indefinitely; titles of works, apps or websites may be protected as titles (see Trade mark and sign law). Where none of these rights applies, protection against imitation under unfair competition law may help. Which combination makes sense depends on the product, the market and the budget.

Licences and contracts

Many copyright issues can be avoided with good contracts: with agencies, photographers, designers and software developers, with employees and freelancers, with licensees and distribution partners. More information can be found under Licensing and Contracts.

Contact

Alexander Ginzburg – copyright, licensing and contracts.

Further areas

Contact

von Bülow & Tamada – Kanzlei für Innovationsschutz, Rotbuchenstraße 6, 81547 Munich, Germany. Phone +49 89 642 30 94, email office@vb-t.com.